Order Scott’s Books:
Top Posts
- A Gentle Rebuke to Brother John (Updated)
- A Baptist Reads RRC and Benefits From It
- On Churchless Evangelicals (Pt 3)
- Calvin500 Schedule, St Pierre Cathedral 5-10 July 09
- For Those Just Tuning in: What is the Federal Vision?
- Audio: Tim Keller and Lig Duncan Discuss the Question of Female Deacons
- URCNA Study Committee Rejects FV (Updated)
- The Heart of the Gospel (and Sola Scriptura Too)
- R. Scott Clark
- Is it Live or is it Memorex?
Recent Posts
- A Baptist Reads RRC and Benefits From It
- The Heart of the Gospel (and Sola Scriptura Too)
- Calvin500 Schedule, St Pierre Cathedral 5-10 July 09
- Lane is Reading William Ames on the HC
- Audio: Tim Keller and Lig Duncan Discuss the Question of Female Deacons
- Exporting Shallowness
- Congratulations to WSC Grads Lenzner and VanderPol
Recent Comments
 | dt on A Gentle Rebuke to Brother Joh… |
 | Hattiebear on Audio: Tim Keller and Lig Dunc… |
 | Benjamin P. Glaser on Calvin500 Schedule, St Pierre … |
 | Daniel F on Children at the Lord’s T… |
 | Bruce on A Gentle Rebuke to Brother Joh… |
Blogroll
- Against Heresies
- Between Two Worlds
- Blogorrhea
- Building Old School Churches
- Calvin500
- Christless Christianity
- Confessio Belgica
- Creed or Chaos
- Creideamh (Iain Campbell)
- Daily Confession
- Daily Westminster
- De Regnis Duobus
- Detergere
- Feeding on Christ
- Geneva Redux
- Gospel-Centered Musings
- Green Baggins
- Heinrich Bullinger
- Helm’s Deep
- Heritage Book Talk
- Herman Bavinck
- In Principio Deus
- διαθηκη
- James Durham Thesis
- Ligonier MInistries
- Mars Hill Audio
- Nick Batzig
- Nicotine Theological Journal
- North American Presbyterian and Reformed Council
- Old Life Theological Society
- Oxford English Dictionary
- Pilgrim People
- Pilgrims and Parish
- Pillar and Ground
- Reason From Scripture
- Ref21
- Reformation2Germany
- Reformed Musings
- Restless and Reforming
- Sean Michael Lucas
- The Confessional Outhouse
- The Confessionalist
- The Continuing Story
- The Conventicle
- The Daily Scroll
- The Gordian Knot
- The Melangerie
- The Reformed Reader
- The Riddleblog
- The Upper Register
- URCNA Discussion List
- Wes Bredenhof
- Wes White
- Westminster Seminary California Morning Devotions
- Westminster Seminary California News
- Westminster Seminary California Subscriptions
Facebook Blog Network
Blog Network:
Category Cloud
Academic Stuff American Christianity Calvin500 Calvin Studies Christ and culture Classic Reformed Theology contemporary evangelicalism Covenant, Justification, Pastoral Ministry federal vision Friends of the Heidelblog Heidelberg Catechism Heidelflogging Historical Theology History of Reformed Theology History of the Reformed Churches I Get Questions John Calvin Preaching the Word Recovering the Reformed Confession Reformation Resources Reformed Ethics Reformed Piety Reforming Evangelicalism reforming worship The Mission: Reaching and Teaching Two kingdoms Uncategorized URCNA News Westminster Seminary California WSC Alumni News
Technorati
Feedjit
Heideltweets
- iPhone up and going AT&T cov good 1 week ago
- Brad and Mark did very well. WSC grad Iwan Baaman is on the floor right now and doing well. 1 week ago
- At classis SWUS (URCNA) in Escondido. Doing the church history exam. The WSC grads are acquitting themselves well. 1 week ago
- The HB passed 700,000 visitors today (since Jan 08) http://heidelblog.wordpress.com Thanks! 1 week ago
- URCNA FV Report Online http://tinyurl.com/qwhz8h 2 weeks ago
2 comments
Comments feed for this article
December 4, 2008 at 4:45 am
David Cronkhite
Scott,
Why not three services on the Lord’s Day?
December 4, 2008 at 7:28 am
R. Scott Clark
Well David, there have been times when Reformed Churches have held three services. This is why the WCF speaks of circumstances as it does. In the 16th century people lived in what we would regard as villages, even though they were regarded as “cities” or “towns.” Everything was within easy walking distance. It would have been unusual to have to hitch up a wagon to go to church. Of course there was a shortage of pastors for the outlying congregations, but that’s still a problem!
In a time when most of our congregations are commuter churches 3 services are not very practical. Indeed, we need to re-think, in some cases anyway, how we do two services — rather than giving up the second service as many NAPARC congregations seem to be doing.
The other limit on the consistory is the freedom of the Christian from tyranny. At a certain point devotion can become tryanny. We’re not monks tied to “canonical hours.” The beauty of two services is that it’s grounded in the creational pattern of morning and evening and in the morning and evening pattern of redemptive history.
We could just as well ask, “why drive cars, after all someone might speed?” The implied argument (if it is implied) that the consistory can’t require attendance to two services because it might lead to three (horrors!) doesn’t work. If a consistory became unreasonable and tyrannical, a member could always appeal to classis for relief and if that failed, to synod. Involved in “circumstances” is wisdom (skill) in applying the Word to a given set of circumstances.